
The Supreme Court recently granted a Petition for Writ of Certioari in Association for Education Fairness v. Montgomery County Board of Education, and will hear arguments early next year. The case involves a parent challenge to Montgomery County School’s revision of its admission policy to its magnet programs. The parents argue that the change–which includes universal screening for test scores and a lottery–discriminates against Asian-American students.
The trial court dismissed the lawsuit on the grounds that the challengers did not allege an actual disparate racial impact on Asian-American students (the County, in fact, argued an aggregate increase of Asian-American students at the County’s magnet schools).
The Supreme Court has now granted review to settle a split of decisions in the lower courts as to whether similar challenges must allege and prove an aggregate discriminatory impact.